Lesson 4 of 7

You Can't Keep Both Size and Shape

Picture stretching a photo of a circle sideways until it's an oval — the area inside might stay exactly the same, but it's definitely not a circle anymore. Or picture squishing that oval back into a circle — now the area probably changed. Map projections face this exact problem with every single country, all at once, everywhere on Earth.

Equal-area maps, like Equal Earth or Gall-Peters, protect size: a country's true size on the globe shows up as its true size on the map. The price is that shapes get bent — a circle on the globe might turn into a squashed oval on the map.

Conformal maps, like Mercator, protect shape and direction: a small circle on the globe stays a circle on the map, and compass directions stay true. The price is that size gets warped, sometimes a lot — a small circle near the pole gets projected as a much bigger circle than a small circle near the equator, even though both were the same size on the globe.

And compromise maps like Robinson or Winkel Tripel don't fully protect either one — they just make sure nothing gets outrageously wrong anywhere, which is why they're popular for general 'here's the world' posters.

For teachers
  • Learning objective: students can state, in their own words, that no projection preserves both area and shape everywhere, and can correctly classify Equal Earth, Mercator, and Robinson by which property, if any, each preserves.
  • Use the Distortion Lab's Tissot indicatrix overlay live during this lesson — seeing the circles stay round (conformal) versus stay equal-area but stretch (equal-area) versus do neither cleanly (compromise) lands faster than any verbal explanation.
  • Assessment idea: show three unlabeled projections' Tissot overlays and have students identify which family (equal-area, conformal, compromise) each belongs to, using only the indicatrix shapes.